Day: March 19, 2024

On her March 7 appearance on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, Lindsay Hubbard revealed what happened to her engagement ring from Carl Radke after the Summer House couple broke up. Explaining that Carl “demanded it back,” Lindsay went on to share that “New York law” made her legally obligated to return the jewelry.

More recently, during his March 14 appearance on WWHL, Carl revealed why he asked for the ring back and how he retrieved the item. 

Carl Radke defends his choice to take back Lindsay Hubbard’s engagement ring 

After host Andy Cohen mentioned how he asked Lindsay the previous week about giving the ring back, he then prompted Carl to give his side of the story. 

“It’s New York state law, it’s my property,” he shared. “I wrote her an email one-on-one and asked for the ring back.” 

Before he continued, The Traitors’ Trishelle Cannatella hopped in with her take: “Carl, no! I don’t like that rule!” she laughed. 

Here’s what you may have missed on Bravo:

Did Lindsay Hubbard Just Reveal There Were Early Signs Her Wedding Was Going to Get Called Off?

Kyle Cooke and Amanda Batula Are at Odds Over Couples Therapy: “We Have Our Challenges”

Here’s Why Paige DeSorbo Was Missing from Summer House

Carl went on to explain: “It is the law in New York state if I purchased the ring and [gave it] on the condition of an engagement …we did not move forward with the wedding, the ring is then returned to me, and that’s just the law. I’m just following the law.”